Color matching

How to match candy coating to an invitation, swatch or brand color

A repeatable way to match a customer’s color in almond bark or candy melts: read the color properly, test dip, let it set, and compare in daylight.

By the Coco Match team. Updated .

crispy rice bars in the color the model predicts for 1 drop of Purple per ounce of bright white candy melts
A 3D render of crispy rice bars, recolored to the color the model predicts for 1 drop of Purple per ounce of bright white candy melts.

1. Read the color properly

The match can only be as good as the color you start from. In order of reliability:

  1. A hex code from the designer, the brand guide or the invitation file. It looks like #9ED9D8 and it means one exact color.
  2. The file on a screen. Open the invitation or logo and pick the color straight from it.
  3. A photo of the printed piece. Take it in indirect daylight with a sheet of white paper in the frame, so you can see how far the photo has drifted. Avoid kitchen bulbs, which push everything toward yellow.

Printed colors and screen colors never agree exactly. If the customer will hold the treats next to a printed invitation, the print is the one to match, so ask to keep a copy on the bench.

2. Choose the coating first

Dye can darken and shift a coating but never lighten it. Icy and pale colors need the whitest coating, and deep colors need a dark one.Pastels and deep colors each have a guide.

3. Expect to blend dyes

Few customer colors are a single bottle. Sage is not “green, but less”. It is green pulled toward gray and warmed. Here are six real targets, each with a common one-bottle guess and the blend Coco Match’s color model picks, scored out of 100 for closeness.

Robin’s egg pretzel rods

  1. Target
  2. One-bottle guess, 59%
  3. Blended recipe, 97%

Caramel latte Oreos

  1. Target
  2. One-bottle guess, 44%
  3. Blended recipe, 100%

Sage green cake pops

  1. Target
  2. One-bottle guess, 76%
  3. Blended recipe, 100%

Blush pink strawberries

  1. Target
  2. One-bottle guess, 91%
  3. Blended recipe, 96%

Lavender cakesicles

  1. Target
  2. One-bottle guess, 68%
  3. Blended recipe, 80%

Butter yellow crispy bars

  1. Target
  2. One-bottle guess, 83%
  3. Blended recipe, 98%
Targets, and the colors the model predicts for each recipe in vanilla and chocolate almond bark with Colour Mill Oil Blend.
ColorOne-bottle guessBlended recipe
Robin’s egg pretzel rodsSky Blue, 2 drops per oz of vanilla almond barkVanilla almond bark, Cobalt, ¼ drop per oz
Caramel latte OreosChocolate, 3 drops per oz of vanilla almond barkVanilla almond bark, Orange 1.5 + Chocolate ¼ drops per oz
Sage green cake popsForest, 4 drops per oz of vanilla almond barkVanilla almond bark, Forest 1.5 + Baby Pink ¼ drops per oz
Blush pink strawberriesHot Pink, 2 drops per oz of vanilla almond barkVanilla almond bark, Baby Pink, 3.5 drops per oz
Lavender cakesiclesPurple, 2 drops per oz of vanilla almond barkVanilla almond bark, Baby Pink 7 + Sky Blue ¼ drops per oz
Butter yellow crispy barsYellow, 2 drops per oz of vanilla almond barkVanilla almond bark, Yellow ½ + Baby Pink ½ drops per oz
The recipes behind the swatches above.
Crispy rice bars in the target butter yellowCrispy rice bars in the color of the one-bottle guessCrispy rice bars in the color of the blended recipe
The same 3D render of crispy rice bars in the target for “Butter yellow crispy bars”, and the two predicted colors.

4. Mix a small test bowl

  1. Weigh 2 ounces of melted coating into a small cup. Thin it first if you thin your dipping bowl.
  2. Add dye by the drop and write down each one. Two ounces at 1.5 drops per ounce is 3 drops.
  3. Stir for a full minute, scraping the sides. Streaks hide the true color.
  4. Dip one treat, or spread a spoonful on parchment as thick as a dip.

Half drops are easier in a bigger cup: half a drop per ounce is one drop in 2 ounces, or two drops in 4.

5. Let it set, then compare in daylight

Dyed coating keeps deepening for about 10 minutes, and set coating looks different from melted. Wait until the test dip has fully set. Then hold it next to the original by a window, in indirect daylight, with something white nearby so your eye has a reference.

  • Too pale: add dye in the same proportions.
  • Too dark: stir in a measured amount of plain coating, and note it.
  • Wrong direction (too green, too pink): add a little of the color opposite the error, one drop at a time.
  • Dull or muddy: more dye will not fix it. Start again from a whiter coating, or with fewer dyes.

6. How close is close enough

Coco Match scores each recipe by how different the two colors look to the eye. The same bands are a useful way to judge a test dip.

Match scoreWhat it means
97 to 100Looks identical. Most people can’t tell them apart.
92 to 96Only noticeable side by side. Customers won’t see a difference.
84 to 91Slightly off. Noticeable next to the original.
70 to 83Noticeably different.
Below 70Very different. Try a different coating or more dyes.

When a color can’t be reached, say so early. Show the customer the closest test dip beside their swatch and let them choose. That conversation is far easier before the order than at pickup.

7. Scale it and write it down

Once the test dip is right, the recipe is the coating, the thinner and the drops per ounce. Multiply the drops by the ounces in the real bowl.The coating guide covers how big that bowl should be. Save the recipe with the customer’s name, because the reorder always comes.

Questions

Quick answers

How do I match candy melts to an invitation?

Get the color as a hex code if the designer has it, or photograph the invitation in daylight next to white paper. Mix a small test bowl, dip one treat, let it set for 10 minutes, and compare it to the invitation by a window.

Why does my coating look right in the bowl but wrong on the treat?

Melted coating is glossy and deep, so it reads darker and richer than it will once set. Dyed coating also keeps developing for about 10 minutes. Only a set test dip tells you the real color.

Can any color be matched in candy coating?

No. Neon and very saturated colors, and some deep colors like navy, are outside what dye in coating can reach. Find that out before you quote, and offer the closest color with a test dip.

How close is close enough?

If you can only tell the colors apart with the two side by side, a customer will not notice. If it looks off from across the table, adjust. Always compare in the same light the treats will be seen in when you can.